1959 AFL Draft Preview
AACA Top 20:
1) Minnesota State (8-1) [Big Western]
2) Mississippi Tech (9-0-1) [SoCon]
3) Iowa State (8-1) [Big Western]
4) Navy (9-1) [Independent]
5) Missouri State (10-0) [MRVC/Big 8]
6) Washington State (9-1) [PAC]
7) Arkansas (8-2) [Independent]
8) Ohio (7-2) [Big Western]
9) Alabama State (8-1-1) [SoCon]
10) Buchanan (NC) (7-3) [Magnolia League]
11) Kansas State (5-4-1) [MRVC/Big 8]
12) Tryon (8-2) [AATU]
13) Alabama A&M (8-2) [SoCon]
14) Lyons (CT) (9-0) [Ivy League]
15) Michigan A&M (6-2-1) [Big Western]
16) Penn (7-3) [ECC]
17) New Mexico A&M (10-0) [Southwestern]
18) Florida State (8-2) [AAC]
19) Genessee (NY) (8-2) [Independent]
20) Indiana Tech (4-4-1) [Big Western]
AACA Bowls:
Rose Bowl (Los Angeles, CA) - (6) Washington State 17-7 (4) Navy
Palm Bowl (Miami, FL) - (18) Florida State 21-14 (2) Mississippi Tech
Magnolia Bowl (Houston, TX) - (12) Tryon 7-6 (3) Iowa State
Columbian Bowl (Chicago, IL) - (1) Minnesota State 14-6 (5) Missouri State
Gold Bowl (San Francisco, CA) - Colorado State 20-13 ULA
Cigar Bowl (Tampa, FL) - (19) Genessee (NY) 19-8 (9) Alabama State
Syrup Bowl (New Orleans, LA) - (7) Arkansas 3-3 (10) Buchanan (NC)
Sun Bowl (El Paso, TX) - (17) New Mexico A&M 13-12 (14) Lyons (CT)
Independence Bowl (Philadelphia, PA) - (16) Penn 27-0 (13) Alabama A&M
AFL Top 25 Prospects
1) OL Phillip Younger - Ohio - DireBear
2) WR Paul Harrison - Penn - MitchSwanson94
3) S Boyd Dove - Colorado State - DireBear
4) TE Jeff Delaney - Missouri - juice
5) LB Gordon Key - Minnesota State - MitchSwanson94
6) WR Nicholas Bartolli - Genesee - MitchSwanson94
7) RB Pervis Fambrough - New Mexico A&M - DireBear
8) DL Frederick Abbott - Alabama A&M - MitchSwanson94
9) OL Eliel Brown - Minnesota State - DireBear
10) DL Roy Semenko - Colorado State - DireBear
11) S Pat Cox - Missouri State - DireBear
12) QB Ron Bennett - ULA - MitchSwanson94
13) LB Devin Melgar - UKC - juice
14) WR Marty Shofner - Tryon - DireBear
15) OL Folke Pettersson - Minnesota State - Dan O’Mac
16) OL Frank Skoronski - Lyons - DireBear
17) TE James Lindsay - Florida State - sevsdast
18) DL Heinz Katzenberger - Pitt State - juice
19) RB Sam Judd - Illinois - sky
20) OL Stan Houser - Michigan A&M - MitchSwanson94
21) RB Oliver Hull - Missouri State - Dan O’Mac
22) DB Jerry Bradley - Kansas State - MitchSwanson94
23) DB Willie Knox - Nebraska State - Dan O’Mac
24) QB Bob Ely - Buchanan - JamHeronArk
25) DL Quincy Jenkins - Michigan - Wallflower
With the Red River Conference collapsing in on itself due to scandal, the newly-minted Athletic Association of Texas Universities (AATU) found itself in a precarious scenario. After the pay-to-play scandal destroyed the conference and three schools bolted elsewhere, they needed at least 1 more school to remain as an eligible conference within the AACA. There were no big schools of the caliber of Texas or Texas State that wanted to touch the AATU with a 10-foot pole due to those schools still being muddied by the lingering effects of the scandal. They had reached out to Arkansas to see if they wanted to rejoin the new conference, but the Gamecocks administration said they would rather remain independent rather than deal with what is essentially the same conference and the politicking between the Texas schools. The AATU would have to look for a smaller school just to stay afloat, and came to an agreement with Texas Industrial out of Lubbock to join the conference beginning this year. The Matadors were perennial conference contenders in the Southwestern Conference, and seemingly saw an option to prove themselves as more than just a small school that could punch above its weight. Their departure from the conference seems to have created a rift between the larger schools in Arizona and New Mexico and the other, smaller schools that can’t reasonably compete with them. They seem likely to move conferences themselves, whether it’s forming a new conference themselves with other larger schools between the Great Plains and the west coast or finding somewhere else to fit in a pre-existing one.
The Genesee Hilltoppers were expected to make a challenge for a second consecutive national title, but two consecutive losses to unranked Pitt State and Army late in the year ended any chances of a national title. They still finished as a ranked team, thanks to a wide receiver tandem of Nicholas Bartoli and Claude Delaney, and got an invite to the Cigar Bowl in Tampa against 9th-ranked Alabama State, where they still proved they were a top contending team with a 19-8 win over the Big Blue. With the Hilltopper’s demise, that left essentially 6 teams to fight for the top spot in the polls. A top 5 matchup between Big Western foes Minnesota State and Iowa State would stand in as a “national title game” and to determine which of the two schools would be deemed the de facto conference champion. It was a decisive victory for Minnesota State, whose anchors on the offensive line of Eliel Brown and Folke Pettersson manhandled their way through the Falcons. The Twisters could have finished the year undefeated, but they were caught napping against a scrappy Indiana Tech team at home just a week later, who handed them as equally as embarrassing of a defeat the Twisters gave the Falcons a week prior. Solely due to that win, the Railsplitters found themselves ranked by the media polls at the end of the year. Minnesota State and Iowa State both finished the year at 8-1, and were both named co-Big Western champions, though the Twisters would get the bid to the Columbian Bowl due to head-to-head. Minnesota State would arguably get the harder bowl game between the two, having to take on the undefeated Missouri State Tigers from the Big 8. The Tigers were led by Bernheim candidate RB Oilver Hull, a slippery back who no one in the Big 8 seemingly could catch, finishing the regular season with a perfect 10-0 record. However, in the Columbian Bowl, Hull finally met his match against LB Gordon Key, who helped lock him down and prevented the Tigers from getting into the endzone as the Twisters won 14-6. The SoCon’s Mississippi Tech Magnolias were the other undefeated team that laid claim to the national title, their only blemish being a tie against conference foe Alabama State. They would have a much easier bowl matchup against the AAC champion Florida State in the Palm Bowl, but the Gators pulled off a narrow 21-14 upset thanks to play from speedy RB Robert Michaels and the pass-catching TE James Lindsay. The final two teams that had any claim over the national title were PAC champion Washington State and Navy, playing another de facto national championship game in the Roses Bowl. Navy RB Roy Luzietti would end up winning the Bernheim, and proved his worth by scoring an incredible diving touchdown to open the game up for the Sailors. Unfortunately for them, the Seawolves would put up 17 unanswered points to stake their claim of the national title. Luzietti would be far and away the top talent in this year’s draft, but after the Roses Bowl he did not declare for the AFL draft and instead is going on to serve his duty in the Navy. Iowa State would have a chance to redeem themselves in the Magnolia bowl against AATU champion Tryon, but the Falcons could not catch the fastest Armadillo on the field, WR Marty Shofner, as he scampered in for the game-winning touchdown as Tryon won a measly 7-6.
The Sun Bowl surprisingly held the only other postseason matchup between undefeated teams, with the Southwestern Conference’s New Mexico A&M Roadrunners taking on the Ivy League’s Lyons Bulldogs, going 10-0 and 9-0 respectively. The Roadrunners were led by senior breakout star RB Pervis Fambrough, who the Bulldogs were barely able to stop all game. Fambrough managed to break free on the last drive, outrunning every Lyons defender on his way for the game-winning score. What became the most exciting out of all the games was surprising between two unranked teams in the Gold Bowl. The Frontier Conference champion Colorado State Mountaineers and their killer defensive unit consisting of DL Roy Semenko and S Boyd Dove were put up against the PAC runners-up ULA Aztecas and Bernheim finalist QB Ron Bennett. The Aztecas came in as the favorite, but the Mountaineers put up an inspiring effort, holding them to just two field goals before the Aztecas put up an inspiring drive to tie the game up at 13. The Mountaineers overcame the odds, putting together one last immaculate drive to put themselves ahead and win their first postseason game in nearly a decade.The least exciting bowl out of all of these was a 3-3 tie in the Syrup bowl between Arkansas and Buchanan. The Owls were riding high off of the QB play of Bob Ely in the regular season, but the Gamecock defense held them to just a single field goal as they couldn’t do anything themselves. A new bowl game was also created in the absence of the Orange Bowl in Orlando, with Liberty Field in Philadelphia hosting the Independence Bowl. ECC winner Penn had the home-field advantage over Alabama A&M. The Cougars played their hands quite well, with the combination of gunslinging QB Jimmy Danforth and WR Paul Harrison proving to be too much for the Eagles, handily winning 27-0.
If the first three picks went strictly off of best players available, then it would go in some order between Penn’s Harrison, Colorado State’s Dove, and Ohio OL Phillip Younger. Younger has made a name for himself in Columbus, receiving the nickname of “the Mule” from his teammates because he is both as strong and as stubborn as a mule. His reluctance to chance seems to be because he already has nailed a lot of the fundamentals to be a top lineman in the AFL. Whether that character issue of him being hard to work will impact his draft stock, but he shouldn’t fall far given that each of the teams picking within the top 4 all need someone to plug in the hole on the line. Despite none of the teams declaring that they need a tight end, Missouri’s Jeff Delaney will be there for them to take the next best player available. Coming from a rugby background, he could easily slot in as a fullback for teams needing the extra bit of power on the run. The Lower Division has also produced a few players teams could be looking at in the early rounds, at the top of which is Ouachita State DB Ray Doyle. His knack to always make the right play at the right time made him the clear standout of the small Arkansas collegiate team. Doyle looks like he’ll be a star, but him playing at a significantly lower tier compared to the other top prospects makes teams question whether he can actually perform at that level or be doomed to compete in the ASPFL for his whole career. California International WR Lou Powell seems to have all the physical skills to be a top wideout in the league, but he’s not rated highly because he’s never played a snap at wide receiver in his footballing career. He actually declared for the AFL draft as a his natural position, quarterback, but he was told he would have a better chance at making into the league by switching to a receiver because of the overwhelming stigma that black quarterbacks aren’t good enough to become a starter. His physicals make it seem like he’ll be a success, but he is seen as more of a dice throw than a guarantee.
Unfortunately, if you’re looking for a quarterback there really is only one option who seems to be starting quality, and that’s ULA’s Ron Bennett. Bennett has the arm and the leadership skills necessary to be a starting QB in the league, but is a liability whenever the pocket collapses. Under him are a few players that have potential, but would need a few years before they could truly be considered for a starting option, which includes the previously-mentioned Bob Ely from Buchanan and Raymond “Red” Kelleher from Ohio. Kelleher is in a similar boat to Bennett, having a strong arm and being weaker on the run, but takes over the game a bit too much if he doesn’t like the call from the sideline. And then below them are the destined-for-the-ASPFL-tier, including Jimmy Danforth from Penn, Mike Blair from Wichita Tech who’s decent all-around but no true defining trait, and Bjorn Dyster from Iowa State with a cannon for an arm but an incredibly hot head.
Draft Picks/Needs:
1 - Chicago Hogs
Picks: 1, 13, 37, 49
Needs: RB OL WR LB DB
2 - Cleveland Crows
Picks: 2, 14, 26, 33 (STL), 38, 48 (NY), 50
Needs: OL LB DB
3 - Buffalo Hammers
Picks: 3, 15, 27, 39, 51
Needs: RB OL LB S
4 - Tri-Cities Hawks
Picks: 4, 16, 21 (STL), 24 (NY), 28, 30 (BOS), 40, 52
Needs: QB RB OL DL LB DB S
5 - Pittsburgh Shamrocks
Picks: 5, 17, 29, 41, 46 (PHI), 53, 59 (DET)
Needs: WR LB S
6 - Boston Dragons
Picks: 6, 18, 42, 54
Needs: OL LB DB S
7 - Washington Federals
Picks: 7, 19, 31, 43, 55
Needs: OL WR LB DB
8 - Cincinnati Rivermen
Picks: 8, 20, 32, 44, 56
Needs: RB OL DB
9 - St Louis Stallions
Picks: 9, 45, 57
Needs: QB RB OL WR
10 - Philadelphia Rattlesnakes
Picks: 10, 22, 25 (CHI), 34, 58
Needs: QB WR S
11 - Detroit Knights
Picks: 11, 23, 35, 47
Needs: OL LB
12 - New York Lions
Picks: 12, 35, 48, 60
Needs: OL TE DB
Comments
Post a Comment